Where Will the Next Generation of Affordable Housing Capital Come From?

Where Will the Next Generation of Affordable Housing Capital Come From?

Where are the investors?

Recent low-income housing tax credits (LIHTC) pricing is now flashing a yellow caution light that has some industry leaders thinking more must be done to reinvigorate LIHTC’s central role in affordable housing. 

Bryan Dickson is one of them.

“I think the biggest issue for the industry right now is the lack of tax credit investors,” asserts Dickson, Senior Managing Director, Affordable Originations at NewPoint Real Estate Capital, a leading commercial real estate finance company.

“If you look at how much tax capacity the insurance and banking industries have, it’s not that much compared to the annual supply of tax credit,” he warns. Today banks account for about 85% of LIHTC investors, with insurance companies, pension funds, corporations, and high-net-worth individuals rounding out the picture.

What prompts Dickson’s concern? What can be done to spark more investment? The 30-year industry veteran shares his insights on what the situation may portend and what steps the industry can take to reenergize LIHTC funding support.

Is there a ‘canary in the cave’ that sparks your unease?

As a matter of fact, there is. A recent deal in California closed at 77 cents a credit. If you’re getting 77 cents a tax credit in California, I can only imagine the difficulty of building something in Iowa. If you rely on tax credits to supply half the proceeds for a deal, any pricing shortfall represents a large funding gap and more sponsor challenges. 

Why the softening interest in LIHTC investment?

I think many assumed there was a nearly infinite appetite for LIHTC investment. Expansion of credit allocations and deals reveals that may not be the case. Then there’s competition from other tax credits, notably energy. Other pressures include changes to the Community Reinvestment Act (CRA). Hundreds of smaller regional banks are being carved out from having to buy tax credits. That does not bode well for rural affordable housing. 

What else is causing headwinds?

The tax credit process is getting more complicated at the state level. Administrative friction now siphons off dollars that should be directed at hard project costs. Overall, we’re making affordable housing development and renovation too complex and difficult.

What do you propose?

We need a more urgent conversation around enlarging the investor base. It may be tempting to simply use CRA to compel more institutional engagement. I don’t believe it’s a wise long-term course to expect banks and insurance companies to shoulder all investment. The participation pool must evolve beyond that.

It may be time to critically rethink Section 469 passive activity loss rules. I believe many Americans would invest in housing tax credits if they could. Unfortunately, that door is closed today. 

I’d also like to see LIHTC dollars insulated from the corrosive effects of administrative fees and consulting allowances. Something similar to this was enacted by Congress to shield municipal bonds proceeds. Maybe it’s time to protect tax credit dollars, too.

Final thoughts?

I think every system gets mired in bureaucratic excess at some point. LIHTC has worked so well for so long. Let’s honor that by considering a reset that we, as an industry, inspire and initiate. Otherwise, we risk having outside voices conclude the tax credit model is no longer sustainable. That would be a tragedy. 

I welcome anyone who shares my belief to contact me. Let’s work together to make the dream of a safe, clean, and affordable home a reality for everyone!     

The editorial staff had no role in this post's creation.