Affordable Housing Leaders Weigh Industry Challenges and Opportunities for 2027

AHF Live State of the Industry Power Panel 2026
Affordable housing executives discuss state of the industry at AHF Live in Chicago. (Matt Rickman)

The economic feasibility of developing new affordable housing communities. The growing prominence of affordable housing on the local agenda. The next generation of affordable housing leaders.

All these issues are bringing challenges and opportunities to the affordable industry, according to executives from The Pacific Cos., Columbia Residential, U.S. Bancorp Impact Finance, Enterprise Community Partners, and Avanath Capital Management.

The leaders discussed these topics and more during the State of the Industry Power Panel at AHF Live in Chicago. The session was moderated by Christine Serlin, one of Affordable Housing Finance’s editors.

Here are several questions and responses from the discussion:

As we head into 2027, what is the single biggest issue that will determine whether the affordable housing industry makes progress or loses ground in the year ahead?

“To me, our affordable housing production system is not particularly healthy right now. There’s a mismatch of what capital is requesting in terms of interest rates, in tax credit pricing, and our ability as developers to feasibly deliver that. I think the theme for 2027 is going to be ‘Can we feasibly start to use the resources we’ve been allocated and deliver projects that actually work?’ The No. 1 test for us in 2027 is going to require different ways of doing things at least for developers and sponsors than we are historically used to … Financial feasibility and economic feasibility of projects is the ballgame in 2027,” said Caleb Roope, CEO of The Pacific Cos., a leading affordable housing developer and owner.

What does the election tell us about what Americans expect from policymakers on housing, and how should the affordable housing should be responding?

“I’m going to be very pointed here in three words: Bedrooms, not ballrooms. That’s what the American voter told us in this election. I want to be very clear that everybody believes affordability is at the center of our politics right now. That is true. But, housing is at the center of affordability … If you look at that chart we just saw from the Joint Center for Housing Studies of how much money a low-income family has left after paying the rent, it is stunning, and it describes exactly what I think the vast majority of Americans are feeling right now at this moment. What I would say is that Congress has gotten the message. They just passed the most comprehensive housing bill we’ve seen in a generation, with more than 90% of both in the House and Senate voting for it. You literally could not get motherhood and apple pie through the Congress of the United States with more than 90% voting for it today. So, that is a massive opportunity, but it’s also happening at the local level,” said Shaun Donovan, CEO of Enterprise Community Partners.

From left, Daryl Carter, Carmen Chubb, and Shaun Donovan share the latest challenges and opportunities for affordable housing. (Matt Rickman)

Does the new political environment create more opportunity or more uncertainty for affordable housing in 2027? Where is there a realistic path to bipartisan progress?

“The points Shaun made about the national landscape are very true, but what I'm seeing, which started probably three to five years ago, is a lot of the action is happening at the local level. We invest primarily private capital, and we've done a number of deals where we're using tools like TIFs, tax abatements, and things like that to drive the returns for our investors to create and preserve affordable housing. We simply do not have enough public capital, in my view, to solve our affordability challenges. It has to also be paired with private capital, which also means that [we have to improve the efficiencies of] programs like Section 8 and others. But, I'm seeing that it's been a lot more action at the local levels,” said Daryl Carter, founder, chairman, and CEO of Avanath Capital Management.

What are some of the issues you're dealing with and some of the solutions you're finding to handle rising costs on the operating side?

“I want to particularly drill down on the insurance point because we track hundreds of thousands of units in our tax credit portfolio across the country. That has been the single-fastest rising piece of the expenses for our properties. We just did a big report on New York, and there was 110% increase over the last decade in insurance. I think this is a big opportunity on the policy side as well. There are a number of states that have taken up insurance reform. It can make a big difference, and they do it in forms that are limiting liability in ways that are smart. New York state, I think, will take it off this year. There are very complicated politics around that, given our legal system. But I think this is a real opportunity for the industry in the coming year at this state level with state regulators. The other thing we're seeing, the most innovative states do, is really isolate the things that are going lower claims. In a lot of the South and places where they're susceptible to tornadoes and storms, it's fortified roofs as an example,” Donovan said.

“We're trying to leverage data and analytics to better understand what is going on, what decisions were made at certain point in time ... And, I would say I spend much more time looking at our sponsors and their portfolios with heavier weights than the transaction that we're looking at itself, which is always going to be important to the next credit, in terms of weighing how to allocate capital,” said Vihar Sheth, managing director of affordable housing at U.S. Bancorp Impact Finance.

What does the industry need to do now to develop and retain talent and build human capacity?

“Now that we're maturing even more in our companies, we're having folks who want to retire. How do we build the capacity of the next generation of leaders? I think it's very important to do and to plan for and to do it much sooner than you think you need to … Last year, on a similar panel, we talked about really investing in staff that is at the property. Those folks you want to retain because turnover is expensive. In addition to that, it’s important to plan for the next generation of leadership, not just in our own companies, in the state agencies, in the industry overall … It's a real issue because it's too complicated right now to just step in and learn. … There's no replacing the human element of leadership and understanding of the complexity,” said Carmen Chubb, president and principal at Columbia Residential.

Complete this sentence: If the affordable housing industry gets one thing right in 2027, it needs to be ...

“It needs to demonstrate it can be responsible with the resources we've been granted to deliver more affordable housing, increase production and preservation commensurate with what we've been allowed to have. That'll be the key, at least a good start, to a healthy start, meaningful production increase numbers. That'll be the win for 2027,” Roope said.

“Collections. Believe it or not, there is still a bit of a COVID hangover, and particularly communities that came out of moratoriums later. I'm sure all of us in the room have collection issues. So, at the end of 2027, if we can get back to 2019, that's what I'm hoping for,” said Carter.

“Don’t stick with the status quo. Innovate, find things that work better, work with your local, state, nonprofit agencies to try to find efficiencies so that there’s less friction in the development and management process,” Chubb said.

“Our ability as an industry, top to bottom, financing, development, allocating agencies, any sort of the support structure, to innovate and turn the allocations into units faster ... We’re exponentially losing ground to complexity and time. And we need to turn that around,” Sheth said.

“It needs to be not letting this crisis go to waste. We are trying to step up at Enterprise. We're just launching a new strategic plan, where we're going to try and reach 5 million people with affordable housing over the next five years, dramatically expand our work. But I want to make it personal as well. Convince that neighbor who’s a NIMBY that affordable housing is something that's good for everybody and every community. … We're really reorienting about what are the most innovative things that can scale to get to those 5 million people. And, all of us can do that in our own ways, in our own organizations. And if we can't do it next year, we're never going to have the opportunity to do it because the wind is at our backs,” Donovan said.

Editor’s note: AI tools were used to assist in summarizing the conference transcript.