Apartment Owner Survey: Constructing the Right Technology Balance
Owners, managers pinch pennies on services such as software and high-speed
lines
Apartment owners and managers are embracing technology that promises
to help them attract and retain tenants, such as high-speed wiring for
new and existing apartments. But they are moving slowly to test out
new online services and are taking a penny-pincher approach when it
comes to new property management software.
The level of technological savvy among owners and managers varies widely,
according to a survey by Apartment Finance Today magazine. The
survey found that only the very largest real estate firms are planning
to spend large sums of money on technology. Smaller firms, which make
up the vast majority of the apartment industry, are still skeptical
of new technology, and many of them don’t yet have Web sites or high-speed
access.
Large percentages indicated they did not use any online real estate
services and did not plan to try them. Many firms showed no inclination
to spend the money that would be needed to set up their staff with new
property management software that takes full advantage of the Internet.
Indeed, many firms are making do with off-the-shelf business software
and are not even using software designed specifically for property management.
Survey characteristics
About 140 real estate companies involved in apartments responded to
the survey. Before analyzing the results, AFT eliminated responses from
firms that had less than $500,000 in annual revenue or did not own or
manage any properties. This reduced the number of firms in the sample
to 101.
Among these 101 firms, the median level of spending on computer hardware
had been consistent and was expected to remain steady. Counting only
the 53 companies that gave spending estimates for each year, the median
level of spending on hardware was expected to be $10,000.
Similar consistency was found in spending for software of all kinds.
Among the 56 firms that gave spending estimates for three years, the
median amount spent on all kinds of software was $4,000 in 1999. The
median figure for expected spending in 2000 was $5,000. For 2001, the
median was also $5,000.
The preceding figures refer to all kinds of software purchases. Spending
on property management software is even lower. Among firms that had
annual revenue over $500,000 and gave answers for all three years, the
median level of spending for property management software was $2,000
in 1999. For the same group, median projected spending was $2,000 for
2000 and only $1,750 for 2001, When firms that managed five or few properties
were excluded, the median projected spending for 2001 was $2,500.
What property management software is most popular?
It was a tie between two software makers. Among firms that managed
at least one property, about 16% said they use software from Yardi Systems,
Inc., and about 15% said they use applications by RealPage, Inc. Just
less than 20% said they do not use any software for management or did
not answer. About 8% said they used general business software, such
as Microsoft Excel or Quick Books. Other software products accounted
for the balance of the responses.
When it comes to the Internet, new online real estate services have
a problem; only a relative handful of apartment industry employees have
regular Internet access.
Among all respondents with more than $500,000 in revenue, the median
number of employees was 26. However, the median number of employees
with Internet access was six.
Among the 91 firms where at least one employee has Internet access,
about 21% were using dial-up modems, which may be too slow to be practical
for online real estate transactions. Thirty-six percent said they had
digital subscriber lines (DSL) or other high-speed Internet access.
Forty-three percent of the respondents indicated that one or more employees
have Internet access but did not indicate what type of Internet connection
they used.
Only about 54% of the respondents said their firms have Web sites,
although the percentage with Web sites increases as revenue rises. Among
firms with revenue of $1 million to $5 million, about 50% had Web sites.
Among those with revenue over $5 million, 62% have Web sites.
New Internet services trying to help apartment owners obtain mortgage
loans have yet to win many converts, according to the survey. Of the
70 respondents that have revenue over $500,000 per year and own more
than five properties, only 11% say they have used an Internet service
to find a loan.
Waiting for next generation software
According to a Real Estate Information Technology Survey conducted
by KPMG Consulting, LLC, and the National Association of Real Estate
Investment Trusts (NAREIT), many real estate technology users are still
waiting for a new generation of software to fully take advantage of
the Internet.
NAREIT’s survey matches the findings of AFT survey, revealing that
about half of the respondents have Web sites, but only a small percentage
are taking full advantage of the Internet to buy, sell or lease a property;
find an equity investment or mortgage loan; or to procure services.
The NAREIT survey examined the business priorities of information technology,
including applications, organization and expenditures. The results also
include predictions for the future.
The results of the NAREIT survey indicate the dominance of five property
accounting and management applications: AMSI, CTI, J. D. Edwards, MRI
and Yardi. While each of these applications is exclusively designed
for the real estate industry (with the exception of J.D. Edwards), users
indicate a strong need for expanded functionality, particularly in the
area of Internet-related capabilities. “The gap between technology needs
and the available package solutions suggests that custom solutions may
be required to take full advantage of the Internet in the near-term,”
said the report.
Also, medium and large REITs are more likely to view Information Technology
as a strategic function, according to the survey results. Close to 90%
of these REITs have a chief information officer or equivalent person
dedicated to technology. Increasingly, this officer is likely to report
to the CEO.
A rise in loan application services
While Internet-related software technologies still have yet to take
off, there is a strong interest in loan application services. Among
the same subset of respondents, 46% said they had not used such services
but planned to try them. Forty-three percent said they don’t use the
services and have no plans to do so.
The Internet was far more popular for buying and selling properties.
Of the 70 respondents that have revenue over $500,000 per year and own
more than five properties, 26% regularly use such services, and more
than half of them could actually name the service they use. Four respondents
named Loop Net, and two named Property First.
Biggest success story: online leasing
The biggest success story is online apartment leasing. Of the 67 respondents
that have revenue over $500,000 per year and manage more than five properties,
28% regularly use online leasing services. However, only 9% could name
the service they use, suggesting a lack of loyalty to any one service
provider. Among the service providers named were Apartments.com and
homestore.com.
Of those 67 respondents, 30% have not used online leasing but plan
to try it soon. About 42% said they don’t use the services and have
no plan to try them.
Another clear winner with apartment owners is the provision of telecom,
Internet and television services to tenants. Among owners that have
revenue over $500,000 per year and own more than five properties, the
percentages who plan to retrofit at least one property to provide those
services is as follows:
- High-speed Internet service: 44%
- Telephone service: 40%
- Television: 43%
Among the respondents who planned to retrofit one or more properties,
the median number of properties to be retrofit for Internet service
was 7.5. For telephone and television service, it was 13.
Among firms that identified themselves as developers, these kind of
services appear to be a routine part of new project planning. Majorities
ranging from 70% to 83% said they plan to install Internet, telephone
and television services in some or all of their new projects.
Return to Table of Contents
|