Affordable Housing Finance
SPECIAL FOCUS
Readers' Choice Finalists
Special-Needs Finalists
AFFORDABLE HOUSING FINANCE
• July/August 2010
FLORENCE HOUSE
Developer: Avesta Housing
Architect: Gawron Turgeon Architects
Major Funders: Northern New England Housing
Investment Fund; MaineHousing; NeighborWorks
America; Genesis Fund; TD Bank; Federal Home
Loan Bank of Boston; Department of Housing
and Urban Development; Maine Health and
Human Services; Portland Housing Authority;
the City of Portland
PORTLAND, MAINE—
Florence House is a haven for homeless
women. In simple terms, the project provides
a roof over people’s heads. But it
is much more complex, delivering three types
of housing in a single building—25 efficiency
apartments, 15 “safe haven” units, and room
for up to 25 emergency shelter beds.
“Florence House has dramatically changed
the conversation around homelessness in
Portland and in Maine,” says Dana Totman,
president of nonprofit Avesta Housing. “Portland
understands that emergency shelters are not the
answer. This is a viable small city model to end
chronic homelessness.”
The second and third floors contain the 25
low-income housing tax credit (LIHTC) apartments
for chronically homeless and disabled individuals
who are able to be more independent.
The first floor houses the safe haven units,
semi-private clusters of personal areas with a bed
and a wardrobe. These are intended as permanent
living space for chronically homeless women
who are not ready for their own apartments.
Some residents have paranoia or claustrophobia,
so the clusters are designed to provide privacy
without feeling constrained.
While the apartments and safe haven units go
a long way to ending homelessness among women
in the area, developers included the shelter to
respond to episodic homelessness.
Florence House embraces the Housing First
model of getting the homeless into their own
homes as quickly as possible. It also is the first affordable
housing development in the state to use
geothermal heating and cooling systems.
Avesta has partnered with Preble Street, the
state’s main provider of homeless services, to offer
a range of programs at Florence House.
Financing for the $7.7 million development
included about $4 million in LIHTC equity from
the Northern New England Housing Investment
Fund and subsidies from MaineHousing, the city
of Portland, Federal Home Loan Bank of Boston,
TD Bank, and the Department of Housing and
Urban Development. —Donna Kimura
MADRONA STUDIOS
Photo: Sally Painter
Developer: Central City Concern
Architect: William Wilson Architects
Major Funders: U.S. Bank; Wells Fargo Bank;
City of Portland; Multnomah County; Oregon
Housing and Community Services; Network
for Oregon Affordable Housing; Federal Home
Loan Bank of Seattle; Homestreet Bank;
Enterprise Green Communities; Energy Trust
of Oregon; Providence Mother Joseph Fund;
Albina Community Bank
PORTLAND, ORE.—
A tired 45-year-old Ramada Inn has been
transformed into an innovative affordable
housing development for the city’s neediest
residents.
The 176-unit Madrona Studios provides permanent
supportive housing, alcohol- and drugfree
units, and workforce apartments for program
graduates and other low-income residents.
Madrona Studios also includes a 70-bed drug and
alcohol recovery center. All have rents restricted
at 40 percent of the area median income.
By creatively reusing the five-story hotel, developers
were able to deliver the units at about
half the cost of new construction, according to
the local nonprofits behind the project, developer
Central City Concern (CCC), which has a history
of serving the hardest to house, and consultant
Housing Development Center.
“Our theme is changing lives and building
communities,” says Ed Blackburn, CCC executive
director. “This project fits so well into that.”
The reuse of the structure is just one of the
ways that Madrona Studios is a green development.
A transit-oriented project that’s helping
revitalize the neighborhood, the building features
an upgraded solar water heating system,
improved insulation with heat reflective
roofing, and a bike room for 130 bicycles.
Madrona Studios, which uses 23
funding sources, required a complex fi-
nancing structure.
To make the $25 million project
work, the ownership of the building was
separated into two legal entities, with
132 units—96 workforce and 36 supportive
housing—on the top three floors
funded largely through $7.1 million in
low-income housing tax credit equity from U.S.
Bank and $5.2 million in tax increment financing
from the Portland Development Commission. In
the second entity, 44 drug- and alcohol-free supportive-
housing units on the second floor and the
first-floor detox center are funded with the help
of $2.8 million in New Markets Tax Credit equity
from Wells Fargo Bank and $3.7 million in bond
financing from the Portland Housing Bureau.
The city of Portland, Multnomah County, and
Oregon Housing and Community Services are
key financing partners. —Donna Kimura
NELSON HOPKINS APARTMENTS
Photo: George Lama Photography
Developer: Olmsted Center for Sight
Architect: Silvestri Architects
Major Funders: RBC Capital Markets; M&T Bank; New York
State Division of Housing and Community Renewal; Dormitory
Authority of the State of New York; First Niagara Bank
LOCKPORT, N.Y.—
Blind and other disabled residents have a
safe and affordable home at the Nelson
Hopkins Apartments.
The 24-unit community is designed to provide
easy mobility and increased safety for its special
population, which often suffers falls and injuries
related to an unsafe home environment.
Developed by nonprofit Olmsted Center for
Sight, the building is loaded with state-of-the art
features, including an emergency call system in
each apartment, adjustable cabinets and countertops,
a talking elevator, and special lighting.
All the apartments, which were set to open at
the end of June, will have at least one independent
individual who is blind, visually impaired, or
has another disability.
The development also answers the issue
of affordability, with the units targeted to those
earning no more than 50 percent of the area median
income. Rents are about 40 percent below
market rents.
By providing safe and affordable homes,
residents can remain independent and live without
barriers, says Milissa Acquard, COO at the
Olmsted Center.
One of the unique features at Nelson Hopkins
is that residents are linked to the National Statler
Center for Careers in Hospitality Service, a program
of Olmsted Center that provides training
and job placement in the customer-service field.
Located in the town of Lockport, a suburb of
Buffalo, Nelson Hopkins overcame the challenge
of finding a national low-income
housing tax credit investor
by turning to local banking
relationships.
The $4.9 million development
was financed with $2.1
million in tax credit equity
from syndicator RBC Capital Markets and investor
M&T Bank. The New York State Division of
Housing and Community Renewal provided the
tax credit award and $2.4 million through the
recently created Tax Credit Assistance Program.
The Dormitory Authority of the State of New York
provided $400,000. —Donna Kimura
NEW CARVER APARTMENTS
Photo: Iwan Baan
Developer: Skid Row Housing Trust
Architect: Michael Maltzan Architects
Major Funders: Citi Community Capital; Los Angeles Housing Department;
California Department of Housing and Community Development; California
Tax Credit Allocation Committee; Enterprise Community Investment; Century
Housing; California Community Foundation
LOS ANGELES—
The New Carver Apartments achieves both
high purpose and high style. Built by the Skid
Row Housing Trust (SRHT), the 97-unit development
provides permanent supportive-housing
units for formerly homeless men and women.
At the same time, it makes a bold statement
that design matters even when serving
the homeless.
New Carver illustrates the importance of design
in facilitating recovery from homelessness
by “making the on-site services functional in the
way they are laid out in the building and by creating
spaces that promote
positive social interaction,”
says Mike Alvidrez,
SRHT executive director.
Designed by acclaimed architect Michael
Maltzan, the dramatic six-story spiral with faceted
walls has attracted public and media attention
for a group that’s often ignored.
The building’s unique shape came about as
a way to mitigate noise from the nearby freeway.
Sound moves around the building’s curves, lessening
the impact.
Inside, a central courtyard and airy decks
aim to uplift residents and encourage them to
be part of the community. Services are also key
at New Carver, with residents having access to
crisis services, health care, benefits advocacy,
and other programs.
Developers used several new financing programs
to fund the $33 million development, including
the city’s Permanent Supportive Housing
Program, which links Sec. 8 project-based vouchers
with the Los Angeles Housing Department’s
housing capital application so developers can
make a single application for both.
It was also one of the first to utilize funds
from Proposition 1C, a statewide voter-approved
housing bond that is providing capital to affordable
housing. And, New Carver is also using the
Tax Credit Exchange Program, which was created
under the American Recovery and Reinvestment
Act to help low-income housing tax credit projects
during the economic downturn. —Donna Kimura
SILVER STAR APARTMENTS
Developer: Trilogy Development
Architect: Economides Architects
Major Funders: Great Lakes Capital Fund; Michigan State
Housing Development Authority; Department of Housing and
Urban Development
BATTLE CREEK, MICH.—
Homeless veterans filled
Silver Star Apartments in
a short 39 days, a strong
show of demand for the 75 permanent
supportive-housing units.
Built on the grounds of the
Battle Creek Veterans Affairs
Medical Center, the development
is the first low-income housing tax
credit (LIHTC) community of its
kind in the state.
The special location required
Marvin Veltkamp and his team at
Trilogy Development to negotiate a
tricky enhanced-use lease to build
on federal land. After lengthy negotiations
with Veterans Affairs (VA)
and the help of Michigan’s U.S.
senators, the developer was able to
obtain a 75-year lease.
Veltkamp is also CEO of Medallion
Management, the leaseholder and managing
agent.
“Flowers, clay, art, and sunlit spaces don’t
work miracles, but they can set the stage in
which miracles occur,” he says. “We have been
able to reach the hearts of these homeless
veterans. We are able to touch their lives and
help them to make changes in their
lives.”
The location benefits the men
and women who live at Silver
Star by placing them close to the
programs at the VA campus. The
majority of residents have been
referred by the medical center.
In addition, Family Home Health
Services provides case management
and other services.
The one-bedroom apartments
come furnished and have their own
patio or balcony.
Much of the financing for the
$8.9 million development came
from $4.7 million in LIHTC equity
from Great Lakes Capital Fund.
The Michigan State Housing
Development Authority (MSHDA)
is providing project-based housing
choice vouchers for all the units, which bring
in rental subsidies to keep rents low. MSHDA
also provided key loans to the project. —Donna Kimura
|