Affordable Housing Finance
SPECIAL FOCUS
Readers' Choice Finalists
Urban Finalists
AFFORDABLE HOUSING FINANCE
• July/August 2009
Families, Former Foster
Youths Find Common Ground
MADISON AT 14TH
STREET APARTMENTS
Developer: Affordable Housing
Associates
Major Funders: Enterprise Community
Investment, Inc.; California Municipal
Finance Authority; U.S. Bank; City
of Oakland; California Department
of Housing and Community
Development; California Tax Credit
Allocation Committee; California Debt
Limit Allocation Committee; Federal
Home Loan Bank of San Francisco
with Mississippi Valley Life Insurance;
Corporation for Supportive Housing;
Northern California Community Loan
Fund; California Energy Commission
OAKLAND, CALIF. Young adults who have nowhere
to go when they age out of the
foster-care system have found
a home at the Madison at 14th Street
Apartments.
“The development provides beautiful,
stable housing for young people
who have been up against the odds their
whole lives, many of whom have never
had a stable place to live,” says Susan
Friedland, executive
director of nonprofit
developer Affordable
Housing Associates
(AHA).
Twenty of the 79
units are dedicated to
former foster youths
while the other units
provide affordable
housing for families.
The eight-story
urban infill project is
the first new affordable
family housing in
downtown Oakland in
nearly a decade. More
than 3,000 people
applied to live at the
property. Household
incomes are from 30
percent to 50 percent
of the area median income
(AMI), but because there are some
Sec. 8 units, the actual income averages
are lower.
AHA worked with First Place for
Youth, a local nonprofit, to pioneer a new
model to address the challenges. They
created a progressive rental program in
which the youths pay an increasing portion
of their rent over a two-year period
as they become more financially independent.
After two years, they become independent
tenants and
are responsible for
their rents, which have
been set at 30 percent
of the AMI. An on-site
services program provides
tools to help the
youths succeed.
The $31 million
project incorporates
green features, including
solar panels that
provide roughly 40
percent of the electrical
common load. The
property also utilizes
a three-tiered parking
lift system to provide
51 spaces where only
17 would otherwise
fit.
—Donna
Kimura
A Fresh Start
in Hammond
GOLDEN MANOR AND
SAXONY TOWNHOMES
Developers: Hammond Housing Authority
and Herman & Kittle Properties, Inc.
Major Funders: Golden Manor: Wachovia
Securities; Indiana Housing and Community
Development Authority; Wachovia Affordable
Housing Community Development Corp.;
City of Hammond
Saxony Townhomes: RBC Capital Markets Tax
Credit Equity Group; Fifth Third Bank; RBS
Citizens/Charter One; Indiana Housing and
Community Development Authority; City of
Hammond
HAMMOND, IND.
Golden Manor and Saxony Townhomes
are erasing the stigma of public
housing. They are the first two phases in
the redevelopment of Columbia Center,
a
1940s-era public housing project that
stretched across 40 acres in this town.
The new developments introduce
mixed-income housing to a site that has been
entirely public housing, according to Maria
Becerra, executive director of the Hammond
Housing Authority. The streets have even been
renamed to signal a new beginning.
The 80-unit Golden Manor serves seniors
and features 76 affordable units for those
earning between 30 percent and 60 percent of
the area median income. The 68-unit Saxony
Townhomes is open to all ages and has 55
affordable apartments that also serve a range
of incomes.
The complexes serve as an example of a
public housing redevelopment done without
federal HOPE VI funds. The HOPE VI program
aims to replace the nation’s most distressed
public housing complexes. Although Columbia
Center was old and obsolete, its apartments
were still functional, making it an unlikely
candidate for those funds.
Partnering with Herman & Kittle
Properties, Inc., an experienced affordable
housing developer, the housing authority
assembled other sources, including $300,000
in city gambling revenues. This was the first
example of Hammond using the funds for
affordable housing.
The team also received about $7.7 million
in low-income housing tax credits (LIHTCs) for
the $8.2 million Golden Manor and $8.7 million
in LIHTCs for the $9.6 million Saxony.
“The developments show what can be
done when public and private organizations
work together,” says Jeff Kittle, executive vice
president and managing director at Herman
& Kittle.
The design embraces the principles of new
urbanism, and a variety of social services are
offered to residents.
—Donna Kimura
Sustainability
Shines at
Oxford Plaza
OXFORD PLAZA
Developer: Resources for Community
Development
Major Funders: Enterprise Community
Investment, Inc.; Wells Fargo; City of
Berkeley Housing Trust Fund; City of Berkeley
Redevelopment Agency; Alameda County;
California Department of Housing and
Community Development; California Tax Credit
Allocation Committee; Federal Home Loan
Bank of San Francisco with Far East National
Bank; Local Initiatives Support Corp.; Surdna
Foundation
BERKELEY, CALIF. Oxford Plaza is a model urban infi
ll and environmentally sensitive
affordable housing development.
That alone would be enough, but the
project aims for more.
Seven years in the making, Oxford
Plaza opened this year along with the adjacent
David Brower Center, a new home
for the area’s many environmental and
social nonprofit organizations. Together,
they form a new mixed-use community
that’s a showcase for sustainability.
“We worked hard on a concept and
made it happen,” says Dan Sawislak,
executive director of Resources for
Community Development, the nonprofit
developer of Oxford Plaza. The city is the
third partner in the overall development,
owning an underground parking garage
for the public and residents.
The effort has created a civic edge
of downtown, adjacent to the University
of California at Berkeley campus and a
block from a regional train station.
Oxford Plaza’s green features include
solar panels that heat domestic
hot water and provide in-floor radiant
heat. A rainwater collection system supplies
“grey” water to irrigate the Brower
Center, which is named after the former
Sierra Club leader. Residents have a rooftop
garden and a playground.
All 97 units are affordable, with
apartments reserved for households
earning from 20 percent to 60 percent
of the area median income. More than
half of the units are two- and threebedroom
apartments to serve families.
There are also units for people with disabilities
and those living with HIV/AIDS.
Approximately 3,500 people applied to
live at Oxford Plaza.
The $40.6 million development offers
on-site after-school programs and
adult education classes. The Brower
Center makes its programs and activities
available to residents.
—Donna Kimura
New Orleans Revival
THE PRESERVE
Developer: The Domain Cos.
Major Funders: Centerline Capital Group; Bank
of America; Freddie Mac; City of New Orleans;
Louisiana Housing Finance Agency
NEW ORLEANS The Preserve is one of the first
mixed-income projects built in
the city since Hurricane Katrina.
Providing 183 units of needed housing,
the development contributes to the
overall recovery of New Orleans, says developer
Matthew Schwartz, a principal at
The Domain Cos.
The Preserve replaces the Crystal
Hot Sauce plant that was destroyed by
the hurricane four years ago and is a
catalyst in the revival of Tulane Avenue
in the Mid-City neighborhood. The city
has contributed more than $1.4 million
to rebuild the streets and infrastructure
surrounding the project.
With The Preserve, Domain has also
introduced a mixed-income housing concept
that has been relatively untested in
the market, according to Schwartz.
The development features 74 affordable
apartments for households earning
between 30 percent and 60 percent of
the area median income and 109 marketrate
units. This 40/60 percent mix was
designed to serve the different incomes
represented in the surrounding area. In
addition, 5 percent of the units are set
aside as permanent supportive housing
with services.
The affordable units were oversubscribed
prior to the development’s
completion at the end of 2008, and the
market-rate units were leased within 90
days of opening.
One of the challenges was the hesitancy
of investors and lenders to put
money into New Orleans. Domain leveraged
its existing relationships to bring
in a core group of investors to the city,
where it hosted several “road shows” to
build confidence in the market. The firm
raised more than $100 million for three
low-income housing tax credit projects.
A $43.2 million development,
The Preserve was financed with about
$16.5 million in tax credit equity from
Centerline Capital Group and nearly
$16 million in Community Development
Block Grants. Bank of America and
Freddie Mac provided an $8.5 million
mortgage.
—Donna Kimura
|